AI uses for records
Eight hours to reject: designing an agricultural delivery quality dataset
By SourceX Editorial · Reviewed by Noah Loul ·
10 sections
Short answer
An agricultural delivery quality dataset should record each load as the receiver saw it: the trade terms, the arrival and unload times that limit rejection, the federal inspection with quality and condition defects kept apart, the temperature record and the outcome settled later. Damage alone does not decide the label. Under 7 CFR 46.44, lettuce sold with no grade stated may arrive with 15 percent damaged heads and still be good delivery.
Checklist
Eight hours to reject
Key takeaways
- The receiver's call has six answers, not two: accept, hold for inspection, reject, accept and claim the seller, claim the carrier, or escalate.
- For truck shipments, rejection must come within 8 hours after notice of arrival and access for inspection, and unloading counts as acceptance.
- Destination allowances mean a load can exceed its stated percentage and still be good delivery; a lot sold as 16 percent tipburn may arrive with 24 percent.
- Quality and condition defects carry different risks, so a dataset that pools them into one damage figure cannot be labeled.
- Store the dock disposition and the settled outcome as separate labels; settlement can take most of a year, and open loads stay open.
What decision does an agricultural delivery quality dataset capture?
It captures the call a produce receiver makes when a load arrives with defects: accept it, accept it and claim an adjustment, hold it for a federal inspection, reject it, route the loss to the carrier, or send a contract question upward. The call is made at the dock within hours, and the right answer depends less on how the produce looks than on how it was sold, when the receiver acted and what the transport record shows.
At a glance
What decision does an agricultural delivery quality dataset capture
Fresh fruit and vegetable trading in the United States runs under the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act, and its regulations in 7 CFR Part 46 define acceptance, rejection, the trade terms and the condition a load must arrive in. Those definitions are why this is a conditional decision rather than a pass or fail inspection. A load with 13 percent damaged heads can be a correct acceptance, and a load with a failing certificate can be one the receiver no longer has the right to reject.
A useful answer needs three things in one record: the decision-time packet, the disposition the receiver chose, and the settled outcome that came later. The examples use fresh lettuce moved by truck, because the regulation gives lettuce numeric destination allowances and lets the casebook below be labeled by a script. Grain, dairy, coffee and processing crops run on other contracts and grading schemes; the record structure carries over, the thresholds do not.
The six dispositions a receiving model should choose among, used throughout this guide:
- Accept: the load meets the contract and its destination allowances; no claim follows.
- Hold for inspection: evidence is incomplete and the rejection clock is still open, so a federal inspection is requested before anything else happens.
- Reject: the load fails, rejection is still available, and notice goes to the seller within the time the rules allow.
- Accept and claim seller: the load fails, but the receiver keeps it, by choice or because an act of acceptance has already happened, and seeks an adjustment backed by the inspection.
- Claim carrier: the load fails because transport was abnormal, so the loss is pursued against the carrier rather than the seller.
- Escalate: the trade terms remove the usual remedies or cannot be read from the record, so a trading manager or counsel decides.
The load packet: seven record groups a receiver already keeps
Every disposition rests on seven record groups that a distributor, packer or retailer's receiving team already keeps, often spread across several systems. The task is to join them for one load and cut them at the moment of the decision, so a model sees what the receiver saw and nothing that arrived afterward.
Two groups matter more to the label than the photos do. The sales confirmation holds the trade term and any grade or condition percentage, and the arrival log holds the times that start the rejection clock. Temperature records are the third: under the federal sanitary transportation rule, 21 CFR 1.908(e)(2), a carrier must give the receiver, on request once the trip is complete, the operating temperature the shipper specified, and must show that it was maintained when the shipper or receiver asks.
The packet, group by group:
| Record group | What it holds | Decision it informs | Common gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales confirmation or purchase order | Trade term, stated grade or condition percentage, contract destination, agreed allowances | Which allowance and which remedies apply | Term written only on the invoice, or changed by phone |
| Bill of lading and arrival log | Pickup time, notice of arrival, time the load was made accessible, unload or diversion time | Whether rejection is still open | Arrival recorded as the unload time |
| Temperature record | Reefer download and the shipper's specified operating temperature | Normal or abnormal transportation | Download never requested from the carrier |
| Receiving notes and photos | Pulp temperatures, defects seen, sample size, who looked | Whether to hold for inspection | Photos with no load or lot identifier |
| Federal inspection certificate | Inspection time, defect percentages, quality and condition defects listed apart | Whether the load is outside its allowance | Inspection requested after unloading |
| Notices and messages | Rejection notice time, seller instructions, protest or counteroffer | Whether a rejection was timely | Notice given by phone with no written trace |
| Settlement records | Credit memo, revised invoice, mediation agreement, complaint file | The settled outcome label | Credit issued with no reason code |
Eight hours to reject: the clock that removes options
For a truck shipment, a receiver who wants to reject has at most 8 hours after it is given notice of arrival and the produce is made accessible for inspection. That limit sits in the definition of reasonable time in 7 CFR 46.2(cc), which sets 24 hours for rail and, for boat shipments, 24 hours after unloading, with provisions for non-working hours.
Two neighboring definitions close the other exits. Under 46.2(dd), acceptance includes any act by the consignee that signifies acceptance, such as unloading or diverting the load, and failing to give notice of rejection within a reasonable time. Under 46.2(bb), refusing to accept without legal justification within a reasonable time, and any rejection that follows an act of acceptance, count as rejection without reasonable cause.
For a dataset, the clock is a computed feature, not a note. Store the notice-of-arrival time, the time the load became accessible, the unload or diversion time and the rejection notice time as separate timestamps, along with the receiving site's working calendar. A model that recommends rejecting a load already moved into the cooler is wrong even when the inspection fails, and the label must say so. A receiver who unloads first and inspects next morning has, in this framing, made an acceptance decision without knowing it.
Good delivery arithmetic: when a damaged load is within allowance
A load can carry more defects than the contract seems to allow and still be good delivery, because the regulations add destination allowances for deterioration in normal transit. Under 7 CFR 46.43(j), produce sold f.o.b. must be in suitable shipping condition, meaning that under normal transportation it will reach the contract destination without abnormal deterioration; where 46.44 sets a good delivery standard, deterioration beyond its tolerance at destination counts as abnormal.
For lettuce, 46.44 gives the numbers. With no grade or condition percentage in the contract, up to 15 percent of heads by count may be damaged by condition defects at destination, including up to 9 percent serious damage, of which up to 5 percent may be decay. Where the contract states a condition percentage, the allowance is whichever is greater: one and a half times that percentage, or the general figures. The regulation's own example is a lot sold as 16 percent tipburn, which could have 24 percent tipburn damage at destination.
Where a U.S. grade is specified, the lettuce may average up to 3 percent condition defects, including up to 2 percent decay, beyond the destination tolerances of that grade; the regulation notes that U.S. No. 1 provides a 12 percent tolerance for damage at destination. The parties may agree other destination percentages, and those then decide good delivery. Each rule is a hard negative waiting to happen: a model that compares the inspection only with the stated grade or percentage will reject loads the rules treat as good delivery.
The allowance arithmetic for a no-grade lettuce contract and for stated condition percentages, computed by the casebook script:
| Contract states | Rule applied | Destination allowance | Hard negative it creates |
|---|---|---|---|
| No grade, no condition percentage | General figures | 15% condition damage, 9% serious, 5% decay | Rejecting a 13% load as damaged |
| 10% of a named condition | Greater of 15% or 1.5 x 10% | 15% | Holding the load to 10% |
| 12% of a named condition | 1.5 x 12% | 18% | Claiming for 16% on arrival |
| 16% tipburn | 1.5 x 16% | 24% | Rejecting 22% tipburn damage |
| Destination percentages agreed by the parties | The agreed figures | As written in the confirmation | Applying the regulation's figures instead |
Quality defects, condition defects and who carries each
Quality defects are permanent and travel with the load from the field; condition defects can develop in storage or transit. That split decides who carries a defect, so a dataset that pools the two into one damage percentage cannot be labeled correctly.
USDA's inspection instructions for potatoes mark each factor as quality, condition, or either depending on circumstances, and describe quality defects as permanent defects that do not change during storage or shipment. Bruises show how fine the line is: at shipping point every bruise is scored as a quality defect, while en route or at destination the inspector decides whether a bruise is old or fresh, and the instructions state that old bruises are quality defects and fresh bruises are condition defects. The FV-300 certification manual has inspectors list quality and condition defects under the certificate's defects heading, condition defects one by one in descending order of prominence with decay last.
Trade terms then assign the risk. Under f.o.b. terms the buyer takes transit risk once the load is aboard in suitable shipping condition. In a delivered sale, 46.43 places transit risk on the seller, and the regulation's example of U.S. No. 1 potatoes delivered Chicago must meet every U.S. No. 1 requirement for quality and condition when tendered there. Shipping point acceptance leaves the buyer no right of rejection, only damages if the load was not in suitable shipping condition, and shipping point acceptance final drops the suitable shipping condition test altogether. When condition defects exceed the allowance and the temperature record shows the trailer ran outside the shipper's specified temperature, transport was not normal, and the claim belongs with the carrier.
Two labels: the call at the dock and the outcome months later
Each load needs two labels: the disposition, judged only against the decision-time packet, and the settled outcome, which can take most of a year to appear. Mixing them teaches a model that the right call at the dock is whatever the later negotiation produced.
The settlement path is long by design. USDA's PACA dispute resolution page says an informal reparation complaint must be filed within nine months of the date payment became due or the other party breached the contract, that mediation can be requested along the way, and that a formal complaint ends in either a reparation order requiring payment or dismissal of the claim. A dataset extracted three months after delivery will hold many loads whose outcome is not yet known.
Those open loads stay in the set as open. Dropping them leaves the quickly settled, uncontested loads, which makes receiving decisions look cleaner than they were. The outcome labels:
| Outcome label | Evidence that sets it | Earliest it can be set | Common mislabel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid as invoiced | Payment matching the original invoice, no credit | Payment date | Treating silence as agreement that the load was good |
| Adjusted by agreement | Credit memo or revised invoice citing the inspection | When the credit posts | Recording the credit as a pricing error |
| Rejected and resold for the seller | Rejection notice, seller instructions, account of sale | When the account is rendered | Labeling the rejection proper without checking the clock |
| Carrier claim | Temperature record, claim filed with the carrier | When the carrier pays or declines | Charging the seller for transit damage |
| Decided in a USDA proceeding | Mediation agreement, reparation order or dismissal | When the agreement or order issues | Using the dock disposition as the outcome |
| Open | No settlement record when the data was extracted | Not final; revisit at the next extraction | Dropping the load or calling it paid |
Casebook: eight lettuce loads labeled by script
The casebook pairs each correct call with the tempting wrong one, because those hard negatives teach a model where the rules bend. All eight loads are illustrative: lettuce shipments by truck written for this guide, describing no real transaction.
Method: the script bin/xs0820_good_delivery_casebook.py in the writer's scratch folder (W09-main-016) applies a fixed rule order, first match wins. Unknown terms or shipping point acceptance final go to Escalate; a missing destination inspection goes to Hold for inspection while the 8-hour clock is open and to Escalate once it has run out; a load inside every allowance is Accept; outside an allowance with abnormal transport recorded is Claim carrier; outside an allowance after unloading, diversion or a lapsed clock is Accept and claim seller; otherwise a failing load still open to rejection is rejected only if the receiver cannot use or resell it, which is a stated business policy, not a legal rule. For a stated condition percentage the script keeps the 9 percent serious and 5 percent decay caps of the general rule, an assumption a specialist should confirm. It ignores non-working hours, U.S. grade contracts and delivered sales, and uses no randomness.
The eight loads and their labels:
| Load (illustrative) | Decisive facts in the packet | Label | Hard negative | What decides it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. No grade stated | 13% condition damage, 6% serious, 3% decay; inspected 5 hours after notice | Accept | Reject because 13% looks bad | Inside the 15/9/5 allowance |
| B. Sold as 16% tipburn | 22% tipburn damage, 6% serious, 2% decay; 4 hours after notice | Accept | Claim for 6 points over the stated 16% | Allowance is 1.5 x 16 = 24% |
| C. No grade stated | 19% condition damage, 10% serious, 6% decay; 3 hours; receiver cannot use it | Reject | Accept and wait for a credit | Outside allowance, clock open |
| D. Same inspection as C | Receiver can use or resell the lettuce | Accept and claim seller | Reject a load it could sell | Stated policy: keep usable product |
| E. Failing load unloaded first | Moved into the cooler 6 hours after notice, inspected afterward | Accept and claim seller | Reject after unloading | Unloading is an act of acceptance |
| F. Failing load, warm trailer | Reefer record above the shipper's set temperature | Claim carrier | Claim against the seller | Transport was not normal |
| G. Visible decay, no inspection | 2 hours after notice; dock photos only | Hold for inspection | Reject on the photos | Evidence incomplete, clock open |
| H. Shipping point acceptance final | Failing inspection; term removes the suitable shipping condition test | Escalate | Reject under the general rules | Remedies limited by the term |
Specialist review checklist before a load enters the set
Each load needs sign-off from someone who has received, inspected or traded produce, because condition typing, clock reconstruction and term reading are specialist judgments. The reviewer's answers decide whether a load is labeled in full, narrowed to its disposition only, or left out:
At a glance
Specialist review checklist before a load enters the set
Checklist · 10 items
- Decision-time cut: nothing in the packet postdates the disposition, including a certificate issued after the rejection notice.
- Trade term: read from the sales confirmation and any written change, not inferred from the invoice or the buyer's usual terms.
- Clock: notice of arrival, accessibility, unloading or diversion and the rejection notice are separate timestamps, checked against the site's working hours.
- Certificate match: the inspection certificate names the same load, lot and arrival, and its time falls inside the clock or is flagged.
- Defect typing: quality and condition defects are kept apart as the certificate lists them, with old and fresh damage classed as the instructions direct.
- Allowance: recomputed from the contract term and any agreed destination percentages, never copied from the receiver's note.
- Transport: the reefer record is compared with the shipper's specified operating temperature, and gaps in the record are marked as gaps, not as normal transit.
- Outcome: set from settlement documents with the extraction date stored; unsettled loads are labeled open.
- Agreement: a second reviewer relabels a sample of dispositions from the packet alone, and agreement is reported with the set.
- Rights and redaction: shipper, carrier and inspector names, prices and contract numbers are removed or generalized unless the intended use needs them and the supplier may license them.
0 of 10 ticked. Tick each item as you go.
What a receiver's records can and cannot show
A receiver's records can teach the structure of the decision and the long tail of disputes; they cannot show by themselves that a model is safe to reject loads. A sector label on a dataset settles neither the rights to license it nor its fitness for a decision with money and food on the line, and that is the strongest objection to this design:
- Thresholds do not travel: the numeric allowances here are lettuce rules from 46.44; other commodities, U.S. grades and agreed percentages need their own sources, and non-U.S. trade runs under different rules.
- Inspections are samples: a certificate reports defect percentages in the units examined, so a borderline load can fall either side on a second inspection.
- Selection: receivers tend to request federal inspections on loads they already doubt, and few disputes go as far as mediation or a formal complaint, so inspected and disputed loads overstate failure rates.
- Outcomes carry leverage: a credit can reflect the relationship, the market price that week or the cost of arguing, not only the condition of the produce.
- Several parties' records: shippers, carriers and inspectors appear in the packet, contracts may restrict sharing, and counsel should confirm what the receiver may license.
- Bounded use: the set supports triage, drafting notices and consistency checks reviewed by a qualified person, not automated rejection of loads.
Writing a request for receiving and claims records
Ask for load packets, not inspection results: the confirmation, the arrival and unload times, the temperature download, the certificate, the notices and the settlement for each load, joined by a load identifier. State the commodities, years and trade terms, the minimum share of loads with a settled outcome, and how open loads are to be labeled.
SourceX looks for datasets like this on request among businesses that hold the records, rather than selling from a stock of data. A buyer's request names the scope and volume wanted, the language and file format, the timing, and the license terms the use requires. Add the intended use and an acceptance test, for example: on a sample of loads, every packet carries the four clock timestamps, every certificate matches its load, and no decision-time packet contains a document dated after the disposition. The supplying company approves the scope and terms and signs before any record moves, and nothing here implies that such records are on hand or that a given set will pass the test.
Frequently asked questions
What is good delivery for fresh produce?
For produce sold f.o.b., good delivery means the load met the contract when shipped and, under normal transportation, arrived within the destination allowances for deterioration. For lettuce, 7 CFR 46.44 sets those allowances in percentages of damaged heads, and the parties can agree different figures in their contract.
How long does a receiver have to reject a truckload of produce?
Under 7 CFR 46.2(cc), the reasonable time for rejecting a truck shipment is at most 8 hours after the receiver is given notice of arrival and the produce is made accessible for inspection, with provisions for non-working hours. Unloading or diverting the load before then counts as acceptance.
What is the difference between a quality defect and a condition defect?
USDA inspection instructions treat quality defects as permanent defects that do not change in storage or shipment, and condition defects as ones that can develop in transit, such as decay. The split matters because under f.o.b. terms the buyer carries normal transit deterioration while the seller warrants suitable shipping condition.
Can an AI model decide whether to reject a produce load?
It can help triage loads, compute the allowance and the remaining clock, and draft notices for a person to approve. Final rejection decisions involve contract terms, sampling uncertainty and commercial judgment, so a qualified receiver or trader should sign off.
When is the outcome of a disputed load known?
Often months later. USDA's PACA dispute page says an informal complaint must be filed within nine months of the payment due date or breach, and formal cases end in a reparation order or dismissal, so a dataset should label unsettled loads as open.
Sources
- 7 CFR 46.44 lettuce good delivery rules: with no grade or condition stated, up to 15 percent of heads damaged by condition defects at destination (up to 9 percent serious, 5 percent decay); a stated condition percentage allows the greater of 1.5 times it or the general figure (16 percent tipburn may reach 24 percent); a U.S. grade allows up to 3 percent condition defects (2 percent decay) beyond the grade's destination tolerances, U.S. No. 1 providing 12 percent for damage; agreed percentages control. Source
- 7 CFR 46.2 definitions: reasonable time for rejecting a truck shipment is at most 8 hours after notice of arrival and accessibility for inspection (rail 24 hours, boat 24 hours after unloading); acceptance includes acts such as unloading or diversion and failing to give timely notice of rejection; a rejection after an act of acceptance is rejection without reasonable cause. Source
- 7 CFR 46.43: suitable shipping condition means arrival without abnormal deterioration under normal transportation, and deterioration beyond a 46.44 tolerance counts as abnormal; delivered sales place transit risk on the seller (U.S. No. 1 potatoes delivered Chicago example); shipping point acceptance gives no right of rejection; shipping point acceptance final drops the suitable shipping condition test. Source
- USDA AMS potato inspection instructions mark factors as quality, condition or either; quality defects are permanent; at shipping point all bruises are quality defects, while en route or at destination old bruises are quality defects and fresh bruises condition defects. Source
- The USDA FV-300 certification manual has inspectors list quality and condition defects under the certificate's defects heading, condition defects individually in descending order of prominence with decay last. Source
- 21 CFR 1.908(e)(2): once transport is complete, a carrier must give the receiver, on request, the operating temperature the shipper specified, and must demonstrate that temperature was maintained when the shipper or receiver asks. Source
- USDA's PACA dispute resolution page: an informal reparation complaint must be filed within nine months of the payment due date or breach; mediation is available; a formal complaint ends in a reparation order or dismissal. Source
Tell us what data you need
Share scope, volume, format, timing and licensing needs. Datasets are sourced on request.